Spread widens between Choice and Select beef
Nov. 16, 2011
by Meat&Poultry Staff
WASHINGTON – Wholesale Choice beef cutout values have climbed, exacerbating the widening spread between Choice and Select beef, which is due to a decline in the price of Select beef that followed a brief increase in cutout values during August, according to the US Department of Agriculture. Choice beef’s strength has been attributed to both smaller numbers of Choice grade cattle and continued large cow and bull slaughter and to Wal-Mart’s decision to sell Choice beef in their stores.
Choice cutout values declined to $180.25 during the second week in September before reaching $189.92 during the second week of November, after peaking at a weekly average of $187.25 per cwt during the last week of August. At the same time, Select beef declined from a peak of $181.75 during the third week of August before declining to a low of $168.70, but then reached $171.43 during the second week of November.
The proportionally large cow/bull slaughter is providing ample supplies of processing/lean beef, which is blended with 50-percent lean trim and, thus, has increased the demand for 50-percent lean trim from Choice cattle.
The tightness in Choice beef supplies is partly due to the motivation to reduce feeding periods because of high costs of feed and feeder cattle, which results in fewer cattle grading Choice. In the face of tight Choice beef supplies, increased demand for Choice product from the retail sector has manifested itself in higher Choice beef prices relative to Select.
Reduced numbers of Choice fed cattle going to market have also resulted in reduced supplies of 50-percent lean trim. Combined with the continued high rate of cow and bull slaughter, these prices for 50-percent trim, from which ground meat products are produced, have also risen. Prices for 50-percent lean trim are currently at record levels, having reached $1.26 per lb. on Nov. 9. Packer margins are reported to be continuing negative and may lead to reductions in cattle slaughter in order to pressure prices for live cattle lower.
In September, Choice retail beef prices set another record at $4.91 per lb., while the retail price for all-fresh beef declined 4 cents per lb. from the high of $4.48 set in August. After a potential dip this winter, retail beef prices are expected to increase year-over-year into 2012.